“Let them produce the original records of their churches; let them unfold the roll of their bishops, running down in due succession from the beginning… as the church of Smyrna, which records that Polycarp was placed therein by John; as also the church of Rome, which makes Clement to have been ordained in like manner by Peter.”
Tertullian, Prescription against Heretics 32 (trans. Thelwall, ANF 3, public domain).public domain
How it works in the game: the move Produce the Records
EcclesiologyArgument · power 70 · 100% accurate
In the gameName your bishops back to an apostle. Smyrna could: Polycarp was placed there by John. Rome could: Clement was ordained by Peter. A book or group that cannot has answered the question.
Learned byThe Primacy Text (Lv 20), On the Unity (Lv 34)
Strong against
×2Gos. Barnabasa book · why?
Tertullian asked for a line of bishops back to an apostle. The Gospel of Barnabas has none: nobody had heard of it before the late Middle Ages.
×2Gos. Judasa book · why?
Tertullian’s test: show your line of teachers back to an apostle. The Gospel of Judas came from a second-century sect, and no church received it from anyone who knew Judas.
×2Gos. Thomasa book · why?
Tertullian’s test: name your bishops back to an apostle. The churches of Smyrna and Rome could. No church ever received the Gospel of Thomas from Thomas.
×2Hidden Sparkan argument · why?
Tertullian asks for names, not beliefs. A teaching that arrived in secret has no list to hand over.
×2Letter to Floraan argument · why?
It claims a tradition handed down privately. Tertullian asks who handed it, and no name is ever produced.
×2On the Unitya book · why?
Jerome reports that Cyprian read Tertullian every day and would say, “Give me the master.”
×2Thirty Aeonsan argument · why?
Tertullian’s answer to a secret handover: the churches with the clearest lists teach none of this.
“The Church, though dispersed … the whole world… has received from the apostles and their disciples this faith… carefully preserves it, as if dwelling in but a single house.”
Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.10.1–2 (trans. Roberts & Rambaut, ANF 1, public domain; condensed).public domain
How it works in the game: the move Rule of Faith
ChristologyArgument · power 55 · 100% accurate
In the gameOne public tradition, handed down openly in all the churches.
Learned byOn the Unity (Lv 26)
Strong against
×4Alien Godan argument · why?
The rule of faith opens with one God, maker of heaven and earth, who spoke by the prophets, and every church said it in public. Marcion’s first claim is the denial of its first line.
×4Gos. Judasa book · why?
And this book is BUILT on that error — it has nowhere left to stand once the rule is read out.
×4Gos. Thomasa book · why?
And this book is BUILT on that error — it has nowhere left to stand once the rule is read out.
×4The Antithesesan argument · why?
The rule of faith says the same God gave the law and sent the Son, and it was said in every church in the open. The Antitheses need two gods; the rule has one, and it is older than Marcion.
×4The Syllogisms of Apellesan argument · why?
Apelles said he believed in one God but could not say how he knew. The rule of faith can say: the God the prophets spoke of, who made the world and sent his Son. It is a belief with its reasons attached.
×2"That’s Three Gods"an argument · why?
Irenaeus points to the one faith held by the churches everywhere: one God the Father, one Lord Jesus Christ, and the Holy Spirit. The church has always named three and counted one God.
×2Hidden Sparkan argument · why?
Irenaeus shows the church has not grown through sharing secrets but by bearing witness (publicly!) to the truth, from Germany to Egypt.
×2Letter to Floraan argument · why?
Ptolemy wrote it privately, to one woman. Irenaeus’ test is a faith said aloud in every church, for anyone to compare.
×2The Traitor’s Handsan argument · why?
Irenaeus points to the one faith held by all the churches together. The Donatists kept a pure church in one province, but the true church is spread through the whole world.
×2Thirty Aeonsan argument · why?
Irenaeus’ complaint was that no two Valentinian teachers described the aeons the same way. He compared their disagreements against the shared and consistent testimony of the church — the Rule of Faith.